Warrant leads to seizure of drugs, gun

January 3, 2025

Five people have been charged after police seized drugs and a loaded handgun following a search of a south side residence.

Thunder Bay Police Service officers with the Intelligence Unit and Emergency Task Unit executed a search warrant at a residence in the 1000 block of Donald Street East on the afternoon of Thursday, January 3.

 

Police seized quantities of suspected cocaine, crack cocaine, and fentanyl. The estimated street value of the seized drugs exceeds $120,000. Officers also seized a firearm, cash totalling more than $13,000 and paraphernalia consistent with drug trafficking.

 

Michelle BENOIT, 39, of Thunder Bay; Delmar FLETCHER, 19, of Scarborough; Trevor HOFFMANN, 21, of Scarborough, a 17-year-old from Bradford, and a 15-year-old from Toronto are charged with the following:

 

• Possession for the Purpose of Trafficking (cocaine)

• Possession for the Purpose of Trafficking (fentanyl)

• Possession of Proceeds of Crime over $5,000

• Careless Storage of a Firearm

• Possession of Loaded Prohibited Firearm

• Knowledge of Unauthorized Possession of Firearm

• Unauthorized Possession of Weapon

• Unauthorized Possession of Firearm

 

BENOIT is also charged with Breach of Judicial Release Order. The 15-year-old is also charged with Possession of Prohibited Firearm Contrary to Order x2, Breach of Judicial Release Order, Breach of Peace Bond, and Breach of Probation x2. The 17-year-old is also charged with Breach of Peace Bond x2.

 

The accused appeared in court on Friday.

 

The investigation remains ongoing.

Theft From Vehicle Prevention Tips

April 24, 2026
The Thunder Bay Police Service is reminding residents to take steps to protect their property when leaving a vehicle unattended. Avoid leaving any unnecessary items in plain view. Thieves often look for quick opportunities, and visible valuables can make your vehicle a target. Items commonly stolen include: • Purses • Wallets • Jewelry • Keys • Electronics and other valuables It only takes a moment of distraction, such as leaving your vehicle unlocked while pumping gas, for someone to steal your wallet or other belongings. Residents are encouraged to remain vigilant and: • Lock all parcels and shopping bags in the trunk of your vehicle • Never hide a spare key inside your vehicle or outside your residence • Avoid leaving personal identification or valuables in your vehicle • Remove technology and other removable accessories from view when your vehicle is unattended Taking simple precautions can significantly reduce your risk of becoming a victim of theft.

Investigation by Intelligence Unit leads to drug seizure and charges

April 24, 2026
TB26012173 A Thunder Bay Police Service Intelligence Unit investigation has led to charges. On April 2, 2026, a home on Algoma Street South was searched with the assistance of the Emergency Task Unit. During the search officers seized over 260 grams of suspected cocaine, 80 suspected Oxycodone-Percocet tablets, 329 suspected Nabilone capsules, over $30,000 cash and other items associated with drug trafficking. A suspect was also located and arrested. The total street value of the drugs seized is an estimated $45,000. As a result of the investigation, 40-year-old Cody VON BARGEN from Thunder Bay is facing the following charges: • Possession of property obtained by crime over $5,000 • Possession of a Schedule 1 substance for the purpose of trafficking – cocaine • Possession of a Schedule 1 substance for the purpose of trafficking – opioid • Possession of a Schedule 2 substance for the purpose of trafficking VON BARGEN has also been charged with aggravated assault as a result of an outstanding warrant. The accused was remanded into custody after their first court appearance with a future court date.

Missing Person Timothy HERRICK, 42

April 24, 2026
TB26015049 The Thunder Bay Police Service (TBPS) is seeking the publics assistance in locating 42-year-old Timothy HERRICK. His family has not heard from him since April 9, 2026. HERRICK was reported missing to the Sudbury Police Service and TBPS is assisting with the investigation. Timothy is described as a white male standing 6’ 2”, weighing roughly 185 lbs, with long brown hair, and a brown goatee. If you have any information about the whereabouts of this missing person, please contact police at (807) 684-1200. Submit tips anonymously through Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-8477, online at www.p3tips.com .